Graduate Qualifying Paper – In Context
Browsing Category

Graduate Qualifying Paper

Graduate Qualifying Paper, Graduate Student, Research, Research Travel

Michaela Piene in Florence and Rome

In September of 2024, graduate student Michaela Piene of the Art History and Museum studies program at the University of St. Thomas received a departmental travel grant to complete her research in Italy in support of her qualifying paper. Michaela’s research focuses on quattrocento devotional art, specifically the usage of visual languages and sensory qualities within the work of Fra Angelico. 

Michaela Peine in Cloister of Santa Maria Novella, Florence

The in-person experience of Renaissance art was key to her research, allowing her to study the material and formal qualities that activate these works of art up close and in a more personal way. She divided her time primarily between Florence and Rome, researching Fra Angelico’s work and hunting for contemporary examples of similar activation in art. A key element of her trip was a visit to the Niccoline Chapel, located within the Vatican Palace. The chapel, entirely frescoed by Fra Angelico, is typically closed to guests, however, Michaela was able to connect with Dr. Fabrizio Biferali, the curator of Renaissance art in the Vatican Museum. Dr. Biferali brought Michaela on a tour of the Niccoline Chapel and provided her with conservation reports, allowing her to study in-depth the architectural and material context of Fra Angelico’s work. The work Michaela did in Italy is key to the research for her qualifying paper, which is advised by Dr. Lois Eliason, and will be presented in December of 2024. 

Michaela in Chapel of the Magi, Palazzo Medici Riccardi, Florence.

Fra Angelico painting in cloister of San Marco, Florence.

Graduate Qualifying Paper, Graduate Student, Research, Research Travel

Elsa Ballata in England

In September 2024, Art History graduate student Elsa Ballata traveled to England with her mother, who proclaimed herself Elsa’s research assistant, to research fan vaulting for her qualifying paper. Over the course of a week, Elsa visited six different sites around the country where she toured buildings and spoke with guides about the history of each location. She spent two days in the Oxford area visiting the staircase at Christ Church College in Oxford and taking a day trip to Gloucester to see the Cathedral and the famous cloisters. After finishing up her time in Oxford, Elsa took a train to London where she visited Westminster Abbey, the British Museum, and a number of other tourist attractions in the city. From London, she took days trips to Cambridge, Salisbury (and Stonehenge), and Canterbury. 

Photo of Elsa peeking out of a cloister stall at Gloucester Cathedral, her favorite fan vaults from the trip, built in the 14th century.

She spent time at each site she visited speaking with the staff about the vaults and history of the buildings, finding the staff to be as excited as her to be studying there. A couple of particularly memorable conversations she had were in Westminster Abbey, where she spoke to a priest before any other members of the public were allowed in the chapel, and with an amazing guide in Canterbury, who spent the week before her arrival researching fan vaults himself so she could ask more questions. It was an amazing experience for Elsa, allowing her to be in the spaces she was studying in person and take notes about details that photos online rarely manage to capture.  

Great Hall Staircase vaults, Christ Church College, Oxford, 17th century.

High vaults of Henry VII’s Lady Chapel, Westminster Abbey, London, early 16th century.

Bell Harry Tower vaults, Canterbury Cathedral, late 15th/early 16th century.

Conference Presentations, Graduate Qualifying Paper, Research

Michaela Peine presenting at 40th Annual Art History Graduate Student Symposium

In the beginning of March, Michaela Peine was invited to present her paper, “Tangible Devotion: A Tactile Understanding of Fra Angelico’s Virgin Enthroned,” an excerpt from her QP research, at the Florida State University 40th Annual Art History Graduate Student Symposium. Presenting this paper gave Michaela an opportunity to hone her research and writing, presenting a facet of her work and receiving feedback that will contribute to her ongoing research.

Michaela’s paper focused on a small double-sided panel entitled Virgin and Child Enthroned with Saints Peter, Paul, and George, Four Angels, and a Donor, painted c. 1446 by Fra Angelico. This research argues that this panel shares many key similarities with deschi da parto—the trays presented to women upon giving birth—b​ut also that it also contains vital elements that mark it as a devotional object, not meant to be given to a new mother, but instead deliberately borrowing the iconography of birth trays in order to operate as an item of devotion for a male donor. Virgin Enthroned is not a static art piece; rather, the physical qualities of this panel reveal that this is an object that is meant to be held closely, turned over, and passed from hand to hand. By understanding the tactile qualities of this painting and imagining the spatial and physical environment it would have inhabited, it is possible to examine the psychological and spiritual narratives within Virgin Enthroned. Through this methodology she seeks to “embody” the piece, understanding its spiritual impact through its sensory qualities. Activated by the physical presence of the viewer, this tiny panel encapsulates the complex relationship between art, religious devotion, civic engagement, and the gendered gaze in quattrocento Italy.

Michaela was invited to submit her paper for publication with Athanor, the graduate publication of the Art History department at Florida State University. Her paper will be published in November, and she will present her QP in December.

Graduate Qualifying Paper, Research, Research Travel

Nicole Petersen in Siena

In September 2023 Art History graduate student Nicole Petersen (@nicole.etal_ travelled to Florence and Siena via a travel grant awarded by the department. They visited Italy to work on their Qualifying Paper project, which focuses on the hexagonal bowl in Pietro Lorenzetti’s “Birth of the Virgin” altarpiece (1335-1342) and how women experienced the work in its original placement in Siena Cathedral.

 

Detail of Pietro Lorenzetti’s Birth of the Virgin altarpiece in Siena

The first photo shows a selfie of them from the top of the Torre del Mangia with Siena Cathedral in the background. The second photo shows one of the many detail photos of “The Birth of the Virgin” they captured to utilize in their paper.

Nicole Peteresen on Torre del Mangia, looking toward Siena Cathedral

Graduate Qualifying Paper, Research, Research Travel

2024 Research Travel: Madeleine DeGrace in London, Kew, and Beaulieu House, Southhampton

In January of 2024, Madeleine DeGrace had the opportunity to complete research for her Qualifying Paper at Beaulieu Palace House near Southampton, the British National Archives in Kew, and the Imperial War Museum in London.

How far along are you in the program?

  • 2 years, this is my 4th semester! I am planning on graduating in December 🙂

What is your area of interest?

  • English country house architecture and their uses in WWII as espionage training schools

Do you work? On campus/off?

  • I have an internship at Minnestoa History Center in their Interpretive Programming division, and I am one of the gallery guards in the American Museum of Asmat Art at St.Thomas

Where were you traveling?

  • I went to England for one week, specifically to Southampton and London to visit Beaulieu Palace House, the Imperial War Museum and the National Archives to see first-hand the sites and artifacts connected to my Qualifying Paper with Professor Victoria Young.

Image of Beaulieu Palace House from January 5th, 2024

Why did you have to go there?

  • It was primarily to view Beaulieu House in person and gather as much information as I possibly could that wouldn’t be available in the US. For architectural research (as with all research) it’s important to see and be in the space you are interpreting, otherwise you don’t really feel a connection to the space. The British National Archives are pretty locked down in terms of online access, so a lot of the primary source documents I needed had to be accessed in person.

What institution/person did you work with at the location?

  • I scheduled a visit with Beaulieu palace house staff to have them give me a private tour walking through the house, and that was quite valuable, but at the IWM and the National Archives, that was primarily led by me. I was able to reserve a ton of documents to view at the national archives and they had them ready for me to look through.

SOE field radio at the IWM’s exhibit on secret operations and spies

What was the content of your research?

  • I was looking at the house and its history, most importantly, looking at how it was used as a training school for the SOE in WWII. Most of the documents I was pulling at the National Archives and the research I was doing at the Beaulieu House focused on the SOE training schools at these sites and how a grand old country house could be used as a training school.

How were your days structured?

  • Most days were a quick breakfast, museum/site visit trip for the whole day, hunker down for dinner and relax. It was pretty lowkey and chill because it was pretty cold and got dark really early, and both my dad and I ran out of steam after a long day of museums (museum fatigue is really real!)

What was your favorite part of the findings/research results?

  • This research is a continuation of my undergraduate senior thesis, in which I studied female agents of the SOE, so for me to get to walk on the same grounds as these women whom I looked up to is really important to me. I found that research so important since many of these women were looked down upon in the immediate post war, so for me to see them in exhibit galleries on walls or to see objects that were connected to them directly was my favorite part of the research. Also, at the National Archives, I pulled out the personnel files of all of the women I studied and to see their handwriting and look through their documents was also so special to me and important.
Madeleine pouring over SOE documents at the national archives

Madeleine pouring over SOE documents at the national archives

Anything else notable about the trip/the work you did?

  • My dad and I drove on the wrong side of the road down country lanes in the New Forest and it was very stressful! But it was very fun! My mom is also a flight attendant for United so we flew standby there and back and we were able to fly business class both ways, which slays.
  • I got to hear Big Ben and St Paul’s Cathedral’s chimes, which was very cool!
Graduate Qualifying Paper, Graduate Student, Research Travel, Uncategorized

Renaissance Florence: Ghirlandaio’s quattrocento goldsmith promotional frescoes

In a seminar on early Renaissance Florentine art with Dr. Lois Eliason, Ingrid became interested in the frescoes of Domenico Ghirandaio (1448-94), one of the most celebrated artists of the late 15th century in Florence. Her research on his Birth of the Virgin (1485-90) fresco in the Tornabuoni Chapel at Santa Maria Novella became the foundation for her Qualifying Paper topic, and draws on a variety of methodologies – including stylistic, feminist, materialistic, and theories about sensory experience in art – to better understand the artist’s work and contributions.

Ingrid at the Tornabuoni Chapel of Santa Maria Novella, Florence

Ingrid had two hypotheses that were crucial to investigate in-person: Firstly, how did Ghirlandaio intentionally introduce sound into his frescoes, creating a multi-sensory experience? Secondly, how did Ghirlandaio’s involvement in his family’s goldsmith business influence his art in comparison with his contemporaries?

Through a travel grant awarded by the Art History department, Ingrid was able to explore these questions onsite in Florence, providing her with an a wealth of contextual information that simply would not have been possible through digital or library research alone. Some particularly valuable scholarly experiences including attending a mass a Santa Maria Novella to experience the acoustics Ghirlandaio would have been working with, and the discovery of a golden plate at the Bargello Museum that was nearly identical to one depicted in Ghirlandaio’s Santa Fina fresco (1477-78). These will be important contributions to her qualifying paper.

Graduate Qualifying Paper, Graduate Student, Research, Research Travel, Students

2023 Travel Highlights: Michaela Peine in Boston

Michaela Peine (she/her) is a graduate student in the department of Art History. She is in her 4th semester at St. Thomas, and plans to finish the program in 5 semesters. Michaela’s area of interest is in the relationship between tangible/sensory qualities and psychological narratives in Italian Renaissance art. When she is not attending classes, Michaela works as a gallery guard at the AMAA, as well as with UST Campus Life. Off campus, Michaela holds an internship with the Cathedral of St. Paul, where she is working with their archives – developing an exhibit connecting their art and architecture to the frescoes in the Sistine Chapel.  

Michaela in Boston!

In 2023, Michaela conducted research in Boston from November 9-14th . With Dr. Lois Eliason as her faculty advisor, Michaela connected with Frederick Ilchman, the chair of European Art at the Museum of Fine Arts. Here are some questions we asked Michaela regarding her research and her time at the Boston MFA: 

Q: What was the purpose of this project? What was the content of your research?
MP: The panel that I’m writing my QP on (here) (Virgin Enthroned by Fra Angelico) is in the MFA collection, and I was able to meet with Mr. Ilchman to examine the panel, dig through their curation files, learn about the provenance, curation, and conservation of the piece. In particular, a lot of my theories about this panel were founded on the question of if it was double-sided. Mr. Ilchman confirmed that the panel was double sided, and I was able to read through the MFA’s documentation of everything that is known about the panel’s reverse. 

Q: How were your days structured?
MP: I spent most of my time at the MFA. I first took a day to visit their collections and my panel again – while I was there, they had an amazing exhibit on that related to many of my research questions. I went back another day to meet with the European Art department and the conservation staff who had worked with my piece. Another day I spent in the Massachusetts Historical Society, where I looked through journals, photographs, and materials relating to the provenance of the panel. 

Q: What was your favorite part of the findings/research results?
MP: In the curation materials about my panel was an old slide with a color photograph of the back side of my panel! The reverse of the panel was split from the painting, and is now separate from the work on display in the MFA, in a (very secret) private collection. This was the first time I saw any image of reverse, and it was incredible to have so many of my hypotheses supported!! I think I sent Lois an email entirely in capslock, out of excitement.  

Q: Anything else notable about the trip/the work you did?
After I finished my work in the MFA, Mr. Ilchman brought me down (through many many levels of security) to the MFA’s collections to show me paintings and works not on display.  At one point he pulled out a rack that had three paintings by Monet.