Michelle Rash – Murphy Institute News
All Posts By

Michelle Rash

All, News

Law Students Challenge Government Immunity Before Ninth Circuit

Murphy Scholars and third-year University of St. Thomas School of Law students Miranda Sharp and Zachary Liebl asked the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit to find the federal government can be held negligent for an unsafe road-design that contributed to their client’s injuries in a car crash.

Working in the Appellate Clinic, led by Murphy Institute co-director Professor Gregory Sisk, the students argued that the United States should not be excused from liability for a dangerous curve on a government-constructed rural highway by claiming public policy immunity.

To learn more and view the full oral argument, read the St. Thomas Newsroom article.

All, Events

Video: “Transparency, Accountability, and Evaluation in the Catholic Church” International Workshop

The international workshop “Transparency, Accountability, and Evaluation in the Catholic Church: A Practical Journey” returned to Rome from 7 to 11 July 2026 for its third edition, bringing together Church leaders and professionals involved in the governance and administration of Catholic institutions.

Since its first edition in Rome in 2024, the initiative has continued to grow, reaching the Philippines in 2025 and Nigeria in 2026 through two special regional editions. From the 31 Church leaders who took part in the first Rome workshop, the initiative has expanded to five workshops across Europe, Asia, and Africa, engaging a total of 433 Church leaders and fostering partnerships with national Bishops’ Conferences and universities.

This year’s edition brought together 29 participants from 15 countries across five continents, including bishops, vicars, and finance officers and treasurers, alongside religious superiors, general secretaries, administrators, and consultants.

Click to watch a recap video with testimonials!
Program on Church Management video screen grab

The 2027 workshop will take place on July 20-24 in Rome, Italy.  For more information and to register, please visit the workshop website.

All, Blog

Student Perspective – Belonging: A Catholic Woman’s Law School Journey

by Gabrielle Tremblay

I was raised in a family of candy-makers and farmers, in a town with a population that could fit in US Bank Stadium over 30 times. Yet I’m now in “the cities” (as northern Wisconsin folk like to call it) with my husband, a lawyer, who has the earning potential to support a large family. And I’m now a soon-to-be law school graduate who has agreed to work at a firm with an 1850 billable hour expectation. What am I doing here?

As a first-year law student, I didn’t know the answer to this question, but my undergraduate education at Creighton University helped me to answer it. It was there that I took a class with two Jesuit priests who walked students through St. Ignatius’s Spiritual Exercises. An essential premise of the Exercises is that God speaks to us in many ways. Importantly, God’s voice is in the people around us and in our deepest desires and passions.

At no time have I heard God’s voice more than these last three years at the University of St. Thomas School of Law. It began when I was a first-year student in Civil Procedure. I couldn’t get enough of personal jurisdiction. It never occurred to me that I could’ve been making fudge at my family’s store or tending a homestead in Wisconsin. For me, none of it would pale in comparison to reading International Shoe or showing up to my midterms with the same rush I used to feel on the eighteenth hole of a big golf tournament. God assured me: I was right where I needed to be.

My love for not only personal jurisdiction, but many other nerdy subjects (proximate cause, the “what is chicken?” case, and, of course, subject matter jurisdiction), made me second-guess my initial plan to practice in family law. Not long into my 1L year, Dean Sisk, my civil procedure professor and co-director of the Murphy Institute, asked me, “Would it be difficult for you, as a Catholic, to represent people getting divorces?” Surprisingly, this question had never crossed my mind. I had seen many excellent family law practitioners who could professionally and brilliantly step into the messiest of human circumstances. I wanted to be that, until I worked in family court the summer after my 1L year. I saw attorneys taking on their client’s burdens to the point of incivility, litigants cracking jokes about their former spouse’s affair, and marriages ending in a matter of a 2-minute zoom hearing. Having been just weeks away from my own wedding, I was living out the tension exposed in Dean Sisk’s question. It was through this tension between my values and the family court room, combined with my desire to learn more about different areas of the law, that God told me I needed to keep my options open.

So, I found myself accepting a position for my 2L summer at a firm with large-corporation clients and an 1850 billable hour requirement. It wasn’t about the money. (In fact, my husband had already accepted a job at an even larger firm.) I saw it as God giving me the power and permission to do what I was passionate about—to explore my various practice interests at a general practice firm and work with people who share my passion for learning. People wonder if I will quit when I have children. As my husband, JJ, often tells me, that would be quite a loss. It wasn’t until my 2L and 3L year that I found the value in myself that JJ has always seen in me.

This began my 2L year while externing for Chief Judge Patrick J. Schiltz. Working with Chief Judge Schiltz, I saw the real-world impact of a Catholic lawyer with a well-formed conscience. He taught me that Catholic lawyers are needed in every area of the law and not just the ultra-personal areas like criminal or family law. In a Catholic Studies class that next semester, I also had the privilege of reading Professor Elizabeth Schiltz’s exploration on motherhood and work from a Catholic perspective. Professor Schiltz not only describes the value of Catholic women in the public sphere, but also, as I have seen being her student in Moral Reasoning for Lawyers, lives it. I started to see my worth as a Catholic woman entering a law firm. I now find nothing more important than setting an example for my future children that they are allowed to bravely chase the desires that God has placed in their hearts.

My 3L year, I was blessed to be a part of Dean Sisk’s Appellate Clinic, where we represented an incarcerated client in his appeal to the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, Dean Sisk showed us his outstanding skill and expertise in appellate work while treating my fellow student representative and me as intellectual equals. And he kept an open heart and ear towards our client. He taught me the value of a Catholic lawyer in the context of a real lawyer-client relationship and gave me the confidence to believe I could make that same impact.

Most importantly, throughout my time at St. Thomas, there was my Murphy Scholar cohort. In true Murphy Institute fashion, my cohort has shown me how to bravely defend a position while maintaining respect and empathy. I’m about to enter workplaces where the witness of Catholic lawyers—like Chief Judge Schiltz, Professor Schiltz, Dean Sisk, and the lawyers my fellow Murphy Scholars will be—is essential. In these spaces, my cohort’s example will play in my mind on the days I need to stand up for my own beliefs and principles.

In short, I am here because of my nerdy passion for civil procedure, a simple but thoughtful question, and the witness of Catholic lawyers at St. Thomas. At St. Thomas, God has made clear not only why I am here, but also that I belong here.

 

Gabrielle Tremblay is a Murphy Scholar and 3L at the University of St. Thomas School of Law.

“Student Perspective” is a recurring blog series which highlights the various activities of the Murphy Scholar graduate students during their fellowship.

All, Blog

Student Perspective – A Visible Church

by Jared Zimmerman

The Catechism of the Catholic Church teaches that the Church is both within history, but also transcends it (Section 770). Additionally, the Catechism states that the Church is both a means by which Christ speaks to his flock and a “visible society.” (Section 771). Why does this matter? Especially to our non-Catholic (or non-religious) friends and neighbors?

It matters because it suggests that there are universal principles which do not solely exist in the realm of abstract thought. Rather than being an armchair philosopher espousing “feel good” principles, a visible Church requires concrete action. Moreover, it calls the individual and community to move from passivity to actively embody the values they profess. For example, is someone who merely makes a social media post about injustice actually creating change? Probably not. Conversely, the Church answers the call of Christ to care for our neighbors not with a post, but by living the values she espoused. For example, the Society of St. Vincent de Paul uses this calling to actively clothe, feed, and house those in need, regardless of religious affiliation. Likewise, the Church calls for us to be more “Christ-like” and one of the ways this is embedded is through organizations like the Knights of Columbus (of which I am a proud member) and the Catholic Daughters of the Americas. These organizations carry out charitable works such as supporting families in need, funding community and parish initiatives, and promoting service, unity, and faith through organized outreach and volunteer efforts. They provide direct and visible support not only to their members and their families, but to their greater community.

This call to visible action is not incidental, but flows from the Church’s very nature. Visibility, in this sense, forces a transition from expression to embodiment. Even if one is a non-believer, the theological or academic logic of a visible Church is still of the utmost importance. This is because it serves as a rallying cry for good and as a banner for universal truths. Additionally, it aids in clarifying moral ambiguity, drawing clearer lines between what is considered good and evil. From a Christian perspective, this visibility is grounded in the Incarnation itself, with God becoming visible and tangible in Christ, rather than remaining purely abstract or distant.

This idea of a visible Church can just as easily be applied to the practice of law. For example, there are Rules of Professional Conduct that obligate lawyers to behave in certain ways and prohibit them from certain actions. This is a visible set of standards that mandates certain ethical behavior and failure to adhere to it can lead to excommunication (disbarment). Likewise, licensing requirements for attorneys serve as a visible threshold of entry into the profession, signaling to the public that certain minimum standards of competence and ethics have been met. Even disciplinary bodies such as state bar associations function as ongoing visible mechanisms of accountability, where violations of professional norms are formally investigated and sanctioned. Similarly, law school can be understood as an early site of formation, where future lawyers are not only trained in doctrine but are called to recognize that legal knowledge carries a responsibility to pursue justice in practice, not merely in theory.

Ultimately, the value of visibility lies in its ability to make principles real and actionable rather than distant and theoretical. In both religious and legal contexts, it is not enough for ideals to exist because they must be lived out in a structured and recognizable way. Without this visibility, even the strongest principles risk losing their clarity and influence in everyday life. This is especially relevant in our modern day, where moral discourse often remains abstract, fragmented, or confined to individual expression rather than collective practice.

 

Jared Zimmerman is a Murphy Scholar and 3L at the University of St. Thomas School of Law in the JD/CSMA program.

“Student Perspective” is a recurring blog series which highlights the various activities of the Murphy Scholar graduate students during their fellowship.

All, Blog

Student Perspective – Transforming Oppression: A Comparison of Ancient Rome and the American Legal System

by Jared Zimmerman

Over the 2025 Fall Break, I had the wonderful opportunity to visit Rome while on my honeymoon. Other than the amazing food and enriching experiences with Italian culture, I was struck by the sheer number of churches throughout the city. Specifically, the number of churches constructed on sites once associated with Christian persecution and martyrdom. What had once been the scene of countless Christian martyrdoms, had now been transformed into a site of hope and thanksgiving. These sacred spaces stand as physical reminders that systems of violence and oppression are not immutable, but capable of redemption and renewal. Likewise, the American legal system, once a system used to justify horrors such as slavery and religious discrimination, can be transformed into a system that truly recognizes that everyone is created equal. Law, like history, reflects the values of those who interpret and apply it. Just as the early Christians transformed the Roman system of persecution and oppression, so too must we as law students and lawyers continue to guard and prevent the legal system from being used to further oppression and discrimination.

While there is a plethora of examples from ancient Rome, one of the most visible and well-known is the Colosseum. What had once been the grounds for innumerable Christian martyrs, executed for their faith to the cheers of a pagan society, was transformed into the Church of Santa Maria della Pietà al Colosseo in approximately the sixth or seventh century. Notably, on Good Friday the Pope leads the stations of the cross in and around the Colosseum, reclaiming a former site of violence as one of reflection and worship. This ritual serves as a powerful reminder that even the most brutal instruments of injustice can be reoriented toward truth, memory, and moral accountability.

Just as the early Christians transformed the Colosseum into a church, so too did Frederick Douglass shift the narrative that the Constitution was pro-slavery, into a fundamentally anti-slavery and pro-freedom document. Douglass went further and argued that when properly understood, the Constitution required  equality under the law. Douglass’s influential interpretation demonstrates that legal texts are not static, but depend upon the moral courage of those willing to challenge unjust readings of the law.

As the heirs of the early Christians and abolitionists, us law students and lawyers now have a duty to help transform the law and safeguard it from being corrupted into a tool of persecution and oppression. This does not require any of us to do the extraordinary, but only the ordinary, such as using our discretion for the betterment of the common good. Likewise, whenever we see an unjust law or even a just law which is being misused to harm another, we have a duty to speak out and to work toward justice through the legal system. This duty may take many forms, including advocating for reform through litigation or legislation, providing zealous and ethical representation to marginalized clients, and refusing to remain silent in the face of injustice. In doing so, we honor both the victims of past injustices and the promise of a legal system rooted in dignity, equality, and the rule of law.

 

Jared Zimmerman is a Murphy Scholar and 3L at the University of St. Thomas School of Law in the JD/CSMA program.

“Student Perspective” is a recurring blog series which highlights the various activities of the Murphy Scholar graduate students during their fellowship.

All, Blog

Student Perspective – Researching Religious Liberty in the Courts

by Georgina Sugrue

This summer, I worked as a research assistant for Dean Greg Sisk, co-director of the Murphy Institute, analyzing data for his ongoing empirical study on religious liberty issues in the courts.  The study began in 1998 with a null hypothesis which states that partisan appointment has no effect on free exercise claims.  So far, the null hypothesis has prevailed, but the study continues as research is divided into ten-year increments. At this time, Sisk’s work is particularly interested in whether judges displayed more bias during years with high COVID-19 case counts. Our summer project specifically focused on how district court judges handled constitutional claims from individuals with diverse religious backgrounds in 2020.   

The research process required coding for the different factors raised in the case, along with specific facts. I began by noting the court, date of decision, the judge’s name, and the overall outcome of the case (whether the religious claimant won on any claims). My focus was specifically on 2020, so I made sure to note if COVID-19 and the resulting restrictions played a role in the claim. I then noted whether the person who believed their religious rights were infringed upon was in court as a plaintiff or as a defendant. Next, I identified the claimant’s religion, which often required additional research beyond the opinion to determine the specific denomination of the individual or organization. I reviewed cases from a variety of traditions, including Catholic, American Baptist, Lutheran, Unitarian, Jewish, Native American, Rastafarian, and others.    

A more detailed analysis was necessary to identify the type of religious claim involved and whether the individual prevailed or lost on it. These issues included the Free Exercise Clause, the Religious Freedom and Restoration Act, the Free Speech Clause, the Equal Access Act, the Equal Protection Clause, and/or the Establishment Clause. Next, I would categorize the type of situation the specific case falls under and the claimant’s religion. I reviewed claims regarding health or safety regulations of private activities, public elementary education, religious solicitation, prisoner claims, employment discrimination against a government employer, and exemptions from anti-discrimination rules.   

As my list of cases spanned across 2020, it was important to note whether each case came before or after the SCOTUS decision in Roman Catholic Diocese of Brooklyn, New York v. Cuomo on November 22, 2020. In short, the Supreme Court reviewed cases in which the government in New York limited attendance at religious services by a church and a synagogue due to COVID-19 concerns, while businesses in the area deemed essential were permitted to have unlimited numbers of people in their buildings. The Court determined that the strict restrictions imposed by the governor of New York were too severe and ordered them to be revoked as they were not generally applicable to citizens, the loss of First Amendment freedoms was likely to cause irreparable harm, and there was minimal public interest in the restrictions. This decision was vital to the lower courts in resolving the large number of cases brought by religious organizations challenging COVID-19 gathering restrictions. 

The next step in this process is for Dean Sisk to review the data and determine whether the null hypothesis has been rejected. If there is a significant conclusion, more writing about the research might follow. Previously, Dean Sisk and Professor Michael Heise have written Muslims and Religious Liberty in the Era of 9/11: Empirical Evidence from the Federal Courts, 98 Iowa L. Rev. 231 (2012), as well as Approaching Equilibrium In Free Exercise Of Religion Cases? Empirical Evidence From The Federal Courts, 64 Ariz. L. Rev. 989 (2022).  

The experience as a research assistant was an excellent opportunity to refine my analytical skills and learn more about the treatment of religious liberty by the courts.  I am eager to see the outcomes of our summer research and review future findings. 

 

Georgina Sugrue is a Murphy Scholar and 2L at the University of St. Thomas School of Law.

“Student Perspective” is a recurring blog series which highlights the various activities of the Murphy Scholar graduate students during their fellowship.

 

All, External, News

“From Leo XIII to Leo XIV: Catholic Social Thought in an Era of Anti-Humanism” – Msgr. Schlag Presents the Fall 2025 Archbishop Ireland Lecture

Murphy Institute co-director Msgr. Martin Schlag delivered the Fall 2025 Archbishop Ireland Lecture hosted by the Saint Paul Seminary.  In his lecture, titled “From Leo XIII to Leo XIV: Catholic Social Thought in an Era of Anti-Humanism,”  Msgr. Schlag offered a fresh perspective on Pope Pius XI’s vision of society’s essential institutions, building on Pope Leo XIII’s legacy and proposing a fourth pillar: the world of work and economic exchange.  Drawing especially from Rerum Novarum, the landmark Church document on labor and social justice recently highlighted by the election and name choice of Pope Leo XIV, Msgr. Schlag set the scene historically, showing how Catholic social teaching evolved from earlier legal and political debates to universal principles that continue to guide the Church today.

Msgr. Schlag was also featured in a recent episode of “Practicing Catholic,” a podcast produced by Relevant Radio and the Archdiocese of St. Paul and Minneapolis, to discuss his inspiration for the lecture.  A recording of the episode and summary of the interview may be found on The Catholic Spirit website.

All, Events, Internal

Video: “Sustainability and Integral Ecology in Business and Law” Conference | Lima, Peru

The conference “Sustainability and Integral Ecology in Business and Law: Ten Years after Laudato si'” took place on July 1-2 in Lima, Peru.  Organized by the Murphy Institute and University of Piura, this event hosted over 80 academics and practitioners from 11 countries to discuss the theological foundations, ethical implications, and practical applications of Pope Francis’ 2015 encyclical.

Click here to view the video.