The University of St. Thomas

November, 2010

Collective Reputations

Published on: Tuesday, November 30th, 2010

In Mentor Externship we spend a lot of time talking about how important it is to build and protect your professional reputation.  It takes a lifetime to build your reputation and a day to destroy it. 

However, how often do we think about how our actions affect the collective reputations related to us?  What we do not only reflects on us but it also reflects on our mentors, our employers, and the other organizations of which we are a part.  I remember when I began at my law firm we had practice group meetings and Saturday training sessions that not only helped with skill development, those sessions also focused on doing things the “Rider Way”.  It was constantly drilled into new associates that when they appeared in court or interacted with opposing counsel their actions not only said something about them, they said something about our firm.  New associates benefited from the great reputation built by those who preceded them and they were expected to conduct themselves in a way that built that reputation not damaged it.

This point also applies to how students conduct themselves in MentorExternship.  Our students are out in the community often.  Our first students worked hard to use the mentor program to build a positive reputation.  Each new class of students benefits from that reputation.  However, each new generation of students also risks destroying that reputation if they do not conduct themselves with the highest levels of professionalism. I hope students always consider how their actions impact the rest of our community. 

Thinking about the larger group is not currently in vogue.  Our culture often emphasizes and even glorifies the individual.  We do not emphasize our collective obligations to one another.  Yet, as a peer reviewed profession part of our professional training is to hold each other and ourselves accountable for how our actions impact not only ourselves but each other too. 

So, whether you are a law student or an attorney, give some thought to how hard others worked to build the reputation of your organization and how your own actions impact that reputation.  I think back to helpful advice one of my own mentors used to give all of us as new associates, borrowed from the old television drama Hill Street Blues, “Let’s be careful out there.”

What Dr. James Andrews Can Teach Us About Client Service

Published on: Monday, November 29th, 2010

In our next Mentor Externship class session we are going to be discussing client service.  How do you become in demand for your clients?  Provide great service to them. Step one is to be available.  It seems simple doesn’t it?  This weekend sportsillustrated.cnn.com had a profile of noted orthopedic surgeon Dr. James Andrews.  Anyone who follows sports knows about Dr. Andrews.  He is famous in sports for being THE medical expert.  What was interesting about this profile, though, is that is looked back on how Dr. Andrews rose to fame. 

So what is Dr. Andrews’ secret?  Patient service.  Early on in his career he established a habit of being available to his patients when they needed him, a legacy he has carried forward to today.  A related secret? He uses the phone or in person meetings, not e-mail. In the article Dr. Andrews describes his approach:

” ‘You see this,’ Andrews said on a recent fall morning, holding up his cell phone. ‘I return calls. Everyone’s calls.  This morning I had calls in from 10 NFL teams, and I’ll get back to all of them today. My whole career I’ve always tried to be accessible. That’s as important to me as anything. If you call me, you know I’ll get back to you.’ ”
http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/2010/writers/the_bonus/11/23/dr.andrews/index.html#ixzz16gyL2I9V

In short, Dr. Andrews built his reputation and his career by developing and sustaining personal relationships.  He takes calls from almost everyone who seeks his opinion.  His former patients, from the famous to the unknown, recommend him to everyone they meet because of the service he provides, the relationships he builds with everyone he treats.

The same lessons can be applied to the law.  Be passionate about what you do and fully service each relationship you establish.  Invest in taking care of your clients when they need you not just when it is convenient to you.  Care about those relationships.  While I can’t guarantee that you will be as well known as Dr. Andrews, clients are always looking for lawyers who care about the service they provide.

A Student Perspective on Key Traits for Mentor Relationships

Published on: Monday, November 22nd, 2010

By J.R. Wise

Reflecting on what has made mentoring meaningful for me, I see three key traits that form a strong meaningful mentor relationship:  (1) Trust; (2) Faith in the protégé; and (3) Compassion.  Two of the most meaningful mentors in my life help illustrate the importance of these traits!

Trust.  The first mentor (outside of my immediate family) I had in my life is a man I call my uncle, Charles Thom (“Chuckie”).  Chuckie entered my life as one of my father’s troops in the USMC.  I was four at the time.  As my father’s subordinate, Chuckie learned to respect my father.  My father encouraged Chuckie to adopt leadership roles and become a role model in the community.  When my father was deployed, he trusted Chuckie enough to move in with our family to look after my mother, brother, and me.  When Chuckie moved in, I initially thought that he was merely my greatest adversary in “Duck Hunt.”  However, as time passed, Chuckie became my soccer coach, my best friend, and to this day, my first mentor.  The trust between Chuckie and me is infinite.  Because of that trust, there has been immeasurable growth in our mentor relationship.  Chuckie is a life coach.  I have trusted him to teach me social development, sportsmanship, and although this is a new endeavor for both of us, dining etiquette.  Without this trust, Chuckie and I would not have a successful mentor relationship.  Without the trust between my father and Chuckie, Chuckie would not have learned to become a mentor.  Without trust, I would not be a third generation mentee; I look forward to mentoring the fourth generation in our chain.

Faith.  The most powerful mentor in my life is Barbara Kalisuch (“Ms. K”).  Ms. K was a high school teacher at Fallbrook Union High School.  She taught the Advancement via Individual Determination course (AVID).  Each year in high school, Ms. K had the incredible ability to turn 30-40 students from underrepresented/underprivileged backgrounds into successful and ambitious students.  I was one of her students.  What made the relationship between Ms. K and me so powerful is the simple fact that she believed in me.  More importantly, she refused to let me not believe in myself and in my potential.  No matter how grim a situation and no matter how rebellious I became, Ms. K never stopped encouraging me.  Because she had faith in me and encouraged me to have faith in myself, I contribute my academic success completely to Ms. K.  Without her steadfast faith, I would be neither a first generation college graduate nor an excelling law student.  The mentor relationship I share with Ms. K grew out of a student-teacher relationship.  The mentoring I do with high school and undergraduate students is a reflection of that mentoring relationship.  Mentoring for high school students and community service projects, I reflect the same faith on to my mentees and on all of my peers.

Compassion.  The most important common denominator in the mentorships I have with Chuckie and Ms. K is compassion.  Only, a compassionate mentor can embrace and embody true mentorship.  When a mentee says, “I can’t.” — A compassionate mentor says, “You can.”  When a mentee says, “I lost.”  — A compassionate mentor says, “You’ve won.”  When a mentee says, “I give up!”  —  A compassionate mentor says, “Try one more time.”

Trust.  Faith in the protege.  Compassion.  When each element is present there is a better chance for a successful and meaningful mentorship.  When a meaningful mentorship exists, new generations of mentors are born.

Creative Problem Solving Skills

Published on: Friday, November 19th, 2010

Lawyers often need to be creative problem solvers.  At the same time, we live in a world filled with deadlines, rules, and stress.  Sometimes those deadlines, rules, and stress box us in and inhibit our ability to creatively problem solve.  So how do you break out of the box and reengage your creative side?

In the August 2010 Edition of the Psychology Today, researchers Darya Zabelina and Michael Robinson of North Dakota State University shared the results of a study on improving creativity.  They found that students did far better on creativity testing after thinking like a seven year old. 

Robinson believes that some aspects of thinking like a kid can activate our creative problem solving skills.  He suggests trying some of the following approaches to improve your creative problem solving:

1) Don’t take yourself so seriously.

2) Find time everyday for one spontaneous activity. 

3) View task as opportunity for explorative rather than duties. 

4) Be present and live in the moment to appreciate fun when it naturally occurs.

5) Resist the argue to fill up all of your free time.

If you are stuck and looking for ways to generate creative solutions, you may want to consider trying Robinson’s suggestions.

Organization and Productivity

Published on: Thursday, November 18th, 2010

Our 2nd Year Mentor Externship students were recently asked to perform a self assessment on their organizational and time management skills as part of a profession on that topic.  They were also encouraged to ask their mentors how they keep their professional obligations organized.  What emerged from our readings, the self assessments, and class dialog was a helpful array of organization and time management suggestions. 

The wide variety of systems that worked for different students and for different lawyers was a good reminder that there is no one solution for organization and time management.  Good time management and time organization requires honest self reflection.  We have to match up our strengths and weaknesses with the tools or organizational systems that work best for us.  We also have to be okay with a system that works best for us even if it doesn’t work for others.  I thought there was a great post on Lawyerist recently on this very topic.  The author, Randall Ryder, raised the excellent observation that the quest for organization can become a distraction in and of itself.  Some people are constantly implementing new systems in the quest for something better.  The end result is a hodgepodge of different organizational techniques and systems that leaves the person worst off than they were to begin with depsite pouring massive amounts of time into their quest.  Ryder’s advice matches the take away from our group discussion; you have to go with the organizational system that works best for you.

Mentor Externship Featured at equippingourlawyers.org

Published on: Wednesday, November 17th, 2010

Mentor Externship is featured this month at equippingourlawyers.org.  Equippingourlawyers.org is a collaboration between the American Law Institute (ALI), the American Bar Association (ABA), and The Association for Continuing Legal Education (ACLEA).  The groups held a critical issues summit in 2009 entitled “Equipping Our Lawyers: Law School Education, Continuing Legal Education and Legal Practice in the 21st Century”.  After the summit the groups prepared a report with recommendations.  You can read the recommendations here. Mentor Externship is highlighted this month as a model for integrating experiential learning and mentoring into legal education.

UST Law named one of nation’s top law schools for externships

Published on: Tuesday, November 16th, 2010

The National Jurist has ranked the University of St. Thomas School of Law number one in the country for externship placements.  Thank you to all of the students and mentors whose enthusiasm and effort make Mentor Externship a success every year!

The Importance of Listening Skills: A Student’s Perspective

Published on: Friday, November 5th, 2010

 By Callie Lehman

Some may say listening skills are a very basic skill set, but in the same sense, it can be a very difficult one. Certain people have a knack for listening and others do not—just like certain people are better at math than others. Listening, especially in law school, is a skill that takes a back seat to the other skills we are learning. Law students are so focused on learning how to read a case, legal write, take notes, and oral argue that we forget to maintain the skills we already have.

 Clients rate lawyers as poor listeners for the same reasons mentioned above—I think poor listening skills develop in law school and carry over into practice. In law school, it’s easier to get away with poor listening skills. For example, while taking notes in class its difficult to keep up with what the professor is saying while trying to jot down what the professor previously mentioned. Or, law school teaches you to multitask which can inhibit listening skills. Law school also teaches us the importance of proving you point, which can lead to interrupting others. All these negative habits that typically don’t present themselves as red flags in law school are definitely red flags when practicing and dealing with clients—not making eye contact, multitasking, interrupting, asking the client to repeat themselves, getting distracted etc. Clients probably notice these bad habits more than a law student would.

I think listening skills should be taught in law school because students tend to focus on mastering skills other than listening. Although, I think some courses already do a good job of teaching it. Take negotiations for example—I have learned so much about listening from Professor Grosland and the class in general. I know my strengths and I know my weaknesses—it’s really nice to have someone honestly critique your listening skills because it’s so important to be a good listener. I am extremely thankful to have figured out my strengths and weaknesses now rather than when I get into practice so I can continue to improve them.

Listening is one of the most important skills in the practice of law, and sometimes we tend to forget that. I really think law school should put more emphasis on listening because it is a practical skill that is necessary to the legal practice!